Cain and Herren, ALC

Practice Areas

About Cain and Herren, ALC

From the firm’s website

Attorneys

• David W. Cain — Partner
• Ben M. Herren — Partner
• Val McKelvey — Partner

Services listed

Employment, Bankruptcy, Personal Injury, General Family Law, Child Custody, Pre-Marital Agreements, Driving Under Intoxicants – DUI – OUI, Llc, Tenant / Landlord Disputes, Estate Planning, Probate, Criminal Defense

Consultations

Free initial consultation

Offices

• 2141 West Vineyard Street Wailuku, Hawai'i 96793

Source: cainandherren.com · checked October 11, 2026. Lawyers Near Me hasn’t independently verified these details.

Hours of Operation

Monday

9 am–5 pm

Tuesday

8 am–5 pm

Wednesday

8 am–5 pm

Thursday

8 am–5 pm

Friday

8 am–5 pm

Saturday

Closed

Sunday

Closed

Photos

Details & Amenities

Related Videos

• Ella Annaheim· via Google

  Ben Herron is an excellent attorney, kind and compassionate and keeps a cool head when the client is stressed. It does take time to get hold of them as they are busy but they are very good, I felt looked after and could rely on them. He won my case for full custody and relocation. Thank you

  6 years ago
• Branden Hazlet· via Google

  Absolute waste of money: inflated billing, terrible communication, never gave me updates on the case just sent me bills, and didn't get anything done at all, totally ineffective representation. $10,000 down the tubes with nothing to show for it. They got very defensive and confrontational as soon as I questioned their billing practices and what time was being used for. I've never written a negative review of any business in the entire life, but this place is a waste of money.

  a year ago
• mollie Klingman· via Google

  Sadly, If I could give a zero I would. The only decent thing they have going for them is their secretary Manny who has always been helpful and professional whether it be on the phone or in person. Their slogan should actually be "The Attorneys without heart" instead of the "Attorneys with heart". We retained the firm to resolve an easement issue on our property and had Michael Collins represent us. He got suspended from practicing law in the midst of our case. We only learned about it from reading the newspaper Maui News. The firm never let us know there was an issue going on with Collins. We were suspect though. His paperwork had numerous grammatical errors consistently. The communications with us, his clients , was very unprofessional. We actually had to personally correct and e-mail corrections back to him. We reached out to the firm after learning about Collins and got a call back from them. David Cain said he would take on our case and apologized about Collins. Well, for a moment, we were optimistic that the head of the firm was taking over, but this was short lived. Cain is even more unprofessional than Collins! Cain has chewed through thousands of dollars without any resolve. Now, not only is our easement issue unresolved, but today, he (David Cain) arrived at a scheduled meeting he had arranged around his schedule. He entered the meeting at his office looking very preoccupied. He was physically shaking, when he walked in. he was short, curt, and after literally two minutes picked up and stormed out of the meeting room. This man, the one we had retained to be our advocate, did not even let us have a proper sit down for a discussion. We are certainly done with this firm. I feel bad, because there was a time this was a respected law firm, but not any more. Steer clear friends.

  4 years ago
• Kimberly O'Farrell· via Google

  The literal worst. I went into this asking for Michael Collins to represent me. Within a few months he passed me off to one of the newer attorneys. Secondly, I had a very real issue that I was dealing with and needed genuine help. I trusted these people, and hoped they had my back. Months into the case, Michael accidentally sent me an email that was meant for his colleagues, and he was saying terrible things about me. This was someone that was supposed to "represent" me and have my back. I definitely do not recommend. I'm still in a terrible situation and this law firm did absolutely nothing for me. The secretary is super sweet, but I wouldn't trust the attorneys with your money.

  4 years ago
• Katie Sodermark· via Google

  A number of years ago I sought out legal help from Cain and Herren. My last experience with a lawyer wasn't good. I really didn't want to file for bankruptcy, but I had to as I was going to retire. I owed a lot mostly from the bad times of 2008. I always pay my bills so I was really fighting doing this. Micheal Collins made me feel much more at ease with my decision. Everything was explained to me. Everyone at Cain and Herren were welcoming. If I need legal help for anything I would return to Cain and Herren.

  2 years ago
• Liz· via Google

  Ben Herren is completely unprofessional. He curses in the courthouse and is easily flustered. Don't hire him unless you want to lose your case.

  a year ago
• Tina Mitton· via Google

  Ben Herren was recommended to me by a friend when I was going through a divorce. I'm very pleased with the work he and Paralegal Sam Castaneda did for me. I received great advice from Ben. Sam was always very responsive and provided wonderful heartfelt support during this difficult time. Manny was also very pleasant. I definitely recommend Cain & Herren and will hire them again if needed.

  2 years ago
• Mark Susskind· via Google

  We had excellent legal help from this law firm. It was easy to make an appointment. They had already reviewed the details of the estate before we arrived. Esther was very professional and communicated in a way that was concise and easy to understand. We were very satisfied with our experience. Highly recommend!

  8 months ago