First American Title Insurance Company

Verified

Title company

5.0(23 Google reviews)

3330 University Ave Third Floor, Madison, WI 53705, United States

Information last updated October 16, 2026

Practice Areas

Real Estate

About First American Title Insurance Company

First American Title Insurance Company, established in 1889, provides comprehensive title insurance protection and professional settlement services. The company facilitates the efficient transfer of real estate through a range of offerings, including Title Insurance, Escrow Settlement Services, and 1031 Exchange services. They also provide specialized support for New Agents, Homebuyers and Sellers, Homebuilders, and Commercial Title Services.

The firm utilizes innovative tools and technology, such as Remote Online Notarization (RON), to streamline real estate transactions. First American Title is committed to customer care, aiming to ensure smooth and stress-free processes. They offer Multicultural Resources, including educational materials in 24 languages and a multilingual website, to support diverse clients.

First American Title has received recognition for its workplace culture, including being listed among Fortune's Best Companies to Work For, Best Workplaces for Women, Best Workplaces for Parents, and Best Workplaces in Financial Services & Insurance. The company also received the PEOPLE® Companies that Care award.

The Madison branch specifically serves Dane, Sauk, Columbia, Jefferson, Milwaukee, and Waukesha Counties in Wisconsin.

From the firm’s website

Services listed: Title Insurance, Escrow Settlement Services, New Agent Services, Homebuyer and Seller Resources, 1031 Exchange, Homebuilder Services, Commercial Title Services, Multicultural Resources, Remote Online Notarization (RON)
Languages: Spanish, Chinese, Hindi
Founded: 1889
Offices: 330 West College Avenue Appleton, WI 54911
300 North Broadway Suite 3B Green Bay, WI 54303
823 Jay Street Manitowoc, WI 54221
3900 Hall Avenue Suite E Marinette, WI 54143
208 South Main Street Waupaca, WI 54981
Awards & recognition: Fortune 100 Best Companies to Work For® 2026
Fortune Best Workplaces for Women™ 2025
Fortune Best Workplaces for Parents™ 2025
Fortune Best Workplaces in Financial Services & Insurance™ 2025
2025 PEOPLE® Companies that Care
DPK Circle of Excellence
Sales Excellence Recognition
Escrow Excellence Recognition

Source: local.firstam.com · checked October 16, 2026. Lawyers Near Me hasn’t independently verified these details.

Hours of Operation

Monday: 8 am–5 pm
Tuesday: 8 am–5 pm
Wednesday: 8 am–5 pm
Thursday: 8 am–5 pm
Friday: 8 am–5 pm
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: Closed

Details & Amenities

Accessibility

Wheelchair-accessible car parkWheelchair-accessible entrance

First American Title Insurance Company — Frequently Asked Questions

Where is First American Title Insurance Company located?+

First American Title Insurance Company is located at 3330 University Ave Third Floor, Madison, WI 53705, United States. Use the "Get Directions" link on this page to navigate there.

What kind of cases does First American Title Insurance Company handle?+

First American Title Insurance Company handles Real Estate. Confirm that they cover your specific legal matter during your first consultation.

How do I contact First American Title Insurance Company?+

Call First American Title Insurance Company at +1 608-236-1300 or visit their website. Many firms offer a free or low-cost initial consultation.

Is First American Title Insurance Company well rated?+

First American Title Insurance Company has a 5.0-star rating based on 23 Google reviews. Ratings are sourced from Google and shown for reference.

Client Reviews

5 reviews

Melissa Willes· via Google
Our family had a pain-free experience at First American Title. Jennifer Monarski was the Construction Lead that helped us finalize our documents. She was incredibly welcoming, genuine, personable, informative and did a wonderful job explaining everything that we were signing. We highly recommend!!
Edited 3 years ago
Terra Beaver· via Google
First time I have ordered sellers title work through First American. They were wonderful to work with. Martin was prompt with his responses and accomidating for my sellers, when one had to sign a few weeks before closing.
a year ago
Rock Cande· via Google
First American Title was recommended to us by our attorney. Brady was extremely professional and easy to work with. My request for information was prompt, complete and was received quickly. Each time I called by phone, I was met with a voice of someone who sounded like they were working in a happy environment. Being a reputable company and being able to help people, these folks know how to make it happen. My thanks.
2 years ago
Jason Holtman· via Google
First American Title does an excellent job with buyers and sellers. Their communication is outstanding. As Realtors, having an excellent title company to work with is paramount to our business, and FATCO is top notch.
a year ago
Wanda Roche· via Google
Every time I have closed at First American it is always seamless and they are prepared and ready for us. Katie and Margaret are the closers that I have used over the years! Outstanding!
a month ago

Other firms in Madison