
On a motion for summary judgment, the judge decides whether a trial is needed: whether the evidence shows a genuine dispute about any fact that could change the outcome. If there's none and the law favors the side that asked, the judge grants summary judgment, and the case, or the part the motion covers, ends without a trial.
This article is general legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by state and situation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your case, talk to a licensed attorney.
Key takeaways
- Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56(a), the court shall grant summary judgment if no material fact is genuinely disputed and the law entitles the moving side to win.
- Unless a local rule or order says otherwise, a federal motion can be filed until 30 days after discovery closes.
- The judge doesn't weigh credibility, but the side opposing the motion has to back its version with evidence beyond its pleadings.
- State deadlines differ: California requires 81 days' notice, Texas allows 21 days to respond, and Florida allows 40 days after service.
- If you can't get the facts you need in time, Rule 56(d) lets you ask the judge to wait.
What is summary judgment, and when does the motion come?
Summary judgment is a pretrial ruling made on the written record the parties file. Under Rule 56(b), a party can file the motion any time until 30 days after all discovery closes, though the 2010 committee note warns that a motion filed before the other side can answer will often be premature. Our guide to how a civil lawsuit works covers the whole case; this table follows only the deadlines that set the summary judgment clock in federal court.
| Step | When | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Complaint filed | Day 0 | |
| Defendant served | Within 90 days | FRCP 4(m) |
| Answer or motion to dismiss | 21 days after service (60 after a waiver request is sent) | FRCP 12(a)(1)(A) |
| Scheduling order | Earlier of 90 days after any defendant is served or 60 days after one appears | FRCP 16(b)(2) |
| Discovery closes | Date set in the scheduling order, which must also limit time to file motions | FRCP 16(b)(3)(A) |
| Motion filed | Default: until 30 days after discovery closes | FRCP 56(b) |
| Opposition (Northern District of California) | 14 days after the motion is filed | Civil L.R. 7-3(a) |
| Reply | 7 days after the opposition was due | Civil L.R. 7-3(c) |
| Hearing | Judge's motion calendar, at least 35 days after filing, or decided on the papers | Civil L.R. 7-2(a), 7-1(b) |
| Ruling | No set deadline; reasons stated on the record | FRCP 56(a) |
Take a case where discovery closes Friday, April 30, 2027, and nothing sets a different deadline. Thirty days later is Sunday, May 30, and Monday, May 31, is Memorial Day, so Rule 6(a)(1)(C) moves the last filing day to Tuesday, June 1. A motion filed that day in the Northern District of California makes the opposition due June 15 and the reply June 22, with the hearing on the assigned judge's first motion day on or after July 6. Those deadlines run from filing, and the local rules say Rule 6(d)'s extra days for service don't extend them. Judges can order a different schedule, and each district writes its own rules.

The judge reads the evidence the parties cite and asks whether a reasonable jury could find for the side opposing the motion. Three Supreme Court decisions from 1986 still set the federal test, and Florida's rule tells its judges to follow them.
Anderson v. Liberty Lobby: "material" and "genuine"
In this libel case, the Court said a fact is material only if it might affect the outcome under the law governing the claim. A dispute is genuine when the evidence would let a reasonable jury return a verdict for the nonmoving party; a scintilla of evidence isn't enough. The judge applies the trial's standard of proof (here, clear and convincing evidence of actual malice). Weighing evidence and judging credibility are jury functions, so the nonmovant's evidence is believed and justifiable inferences go its way.
Celotex v. Catrett: pointing to what's missing
A woman sued several companies, alleging her husband's 1979 death came from exposure to their asbestos products, and Celotex said she had no evidence he was exposed to its products. The Court held that a party without the burden of proof at trial needn't file affidavits disproving the claim. It can identify the gap, and the other side must then go beyond its pleadings with affidavits, depositions, interrogatory answers or admissions showing a genuine issue for trial.
Matsushita v. Zenith: when the story doesn't add up
American television makers accused Japanese competitors of conspiring to drive them from the U.S. market with low prices. The Court said the opposing side must do more than show "some metaphysical doubt" about the facts, and a claim that makes no economic sense needs more persuasive evidence than usual.
A genuine dispute versus one that changes nothing
Say a contractor sues a homeowner over an unpaid final invoice, and her defense is that the job was never finished. The contractor moves for summary judgment with a declaration saying the work was completed. If she files her own declaration describing the unfinished work, with dated photos, there's a genuine dispute about a material fact: whether the work was done decides who owes what, and a jury could believe either of them. Arguing over whether the contract was signed on a Tuesday or a Wednesday won't stop the motion, because the signing day doesn't affect the outcome. If she relies only on the denial in her answer, Rule 56(e) lets the judge treat the contractor's account as undisputed.
Federal and state summary judgment rules compared
The question is much the same in all five systems (Florida adopted the federal standard in 2021), but the paperwork and deadlines differ. Other states have their own rules, and judges can change the schedule by order.
| Court and rule | Who may move, and when | Response and reply | No-evidence motion? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Federal: FRCP 56 | Any party; until 30 days after discovery closes unless a local rule or order differs | Set by local rule or order | No, but a party can show the other side "cannot produce admissible evidence" (56(c)(1)(B)) |
| California: Code Civ. Proc. 437c | Any party, 60 days after each opposing party's general appearance; heard at least 30 days before trial | Motion served 81 days before the hearing (more by mail); opposition 20 days before; reply 11 days before | No, but a defendant can show an element "cannot be established" (437c(p)(2)) |
| Texas: Rule 166a (for motions filed on or after March 1, 2026) | Traditional motion after the other side appears or answers; no-evidence motion after adequate time for discovery | Response 21 days after filing; reply 7 days after the response; hearing or submission more than 35 and no more than 60 days after filing (up to 90 in some cases); ruling within 90 days after that | Yes: it must name the elements lacking evidence, and the court must grant it unless the response raises a genuine issue |
| New York: CPLR 3212 | Any party after issue is joined; within 120 days after the note of issue unless the court sets a date or grants leave for good cause | CPLR 2214(b): 8 days' notice and answering papers 2 days before; with 16 days' notice and a demand, 7 days and 1 day for reply | No; the motion needs an affidavit from someone with knowledge, the pleadings and other proof |
| Florida: Rule 1.510 | Any party, 20 days after the case begins, within any court-ordered deadline | Response within 40 days after service of the motion; hearing at least 10 days after that deadline | No, but it uses the federal "cannot produce admissible evidence" text |
California counts backward from the hearing, Texas and the Northern District of California count forward from filing, and Florida counts from service. California's deadlines changed on January 1, 2025 and Texas's on March 1, 2026, so older forms may show the wrong numbers.

Rule 56(c)(1) requires a party who says a fact is disputed to cite particular parts of the record: deposition pages, documents, declarations, interrogatory answers, admissions. A brief that only argues the other side is wrong gives the judge nothing to weigh.
The evidence you need
A declaration must be made on personal knowledge, set out admissible facts, and show the person is competent to testify about them (Rule 56(c)(4)). In federal court, a signed, dated statement declaring under penalty of perjury that it's true and correct can replace a sworn affidavit (28 U.S.C. 1746). Each witness should describe what they saw or did, with dates. Cite exact deposition pages, and file them if they aren't in the record. You can object that the other side's material couldn't be presented in admissible form (Rule 56(c)(2)); in California, evidentiary objections not made at the hearing are waived. A bad-faith declaration can lead to an order to pay the other side's fees (Rule 56(h)).
The separate statement, where the court requires one
California requires one from both sides. Yours must answer each fact the moving party calls undisputed, say whether you agree, and cite evidence for each fact you dispute; leaving it out can, in the judge's discretion, be enough to grant the motion (437c(b)(3)). Federal courts vary: the Rule 56 committee note says some want a separate statement of facts, and the Northern District of California allows none unless the judge orders one (Civil L.R. 56-2). Check your district's local rules and your judge's standing order.
Rule 56(d) when you need more discovery
If you can't yet present facts essential to your opposition, file a declaration giving specific reasons. The court can defer or deny the motion, allow time for more discovery, or make another order, and the committee note says you can ask it to push back your response date. Say what evidence you need, who has it and why you don't have it yet. If the other side holds it, our guide to the civil lawsuit discovery process explains the requests and depositions that get it. State versions include California's section 437c(h) (which allows an ex parte request up to the day the opposition is due), Texas Rule 166a(d)(3), CPLR 3212(f) and Florida's rule 1.510(d).
Partial summary judgment
A motion can target one claim, one defense or part of one (Rule 56(a)), and if the judge grants less than was asked, Rule 56(g) allows an order treating specific undisputed facts, such as an item of damages, as established for trial. California's version, summary adjudication, is granted only if it completely disposes of a cause of action, an affirmative defense, a claim for punitive damages or an issue of duty (437c(f)(1)).
If you're facing a motion without a lawyer
Calendar the response deadline the day the motion arrives, using your court's rule, because a fact you don't properly address can be treated as undisputed. Many courts warn self-represented parties about that risk, the Rule 56 committee note says, but don't count on it. Get a lawyer's help quickly if:
- the motion would end your whole case, or the claim you care most about;
- you need discovery you haven't received and have to write a Rule 56(d) declaration;
- your court requires a separate statement and you've never prepared one;
- the motion rests on an expert whose opinion you'd need your own expert to answer.
You can ask a lawyer to review your draft opposition rather than take the whole case. If money is the obstacle, see how to get a lawyer with no money, or find a civil litigation lawyer near you in our directory.
Frequently asked questions
What's the difference between a motion to dismiss and summary judgment?
A motion to dismiss under Federal Rule 12(b)(6) argues the complaint fails to state a claim the court can grant relief on, so it tests the pleading. Summary judgment tests the evidence. If a party attaches outside evidence to a motion to dismiss and the judge doesn't exclude it, Rule 12(d) requires the court to treat it as a summary judgment motion and let every party respond.
What happens if you don't respond to a motion for summary judgment?
The motion isn't granted automatically in federal court. The Rule 56 committee note says summary judgment can't be granted by default, but under Rule 56(e) the judge may treat the moving side's facts as undisputed and grant the motion if those facts show it's entitled to win. In California, skipping the required separate statement can alone justify granting it.
Can a judge grant summary judgment if no one asked for it?
Yes, in federal court, after notice and a reasonable time to respond. Rule 56(f) lets the judge grant summary judgment for the side that didn't move, grant a motion on grounds no party raised, or consider it on the court's own initiative after identifying the facts that may not be genuinely disputed. Florida's rule 1.510(f) uses the same wording.
Can you appeal a summary judgment ruling?
A grant that ends the whole case is a final decision, and federal courts of appeals hear appeals from final decisions under 28 U.S.C. 1291. Appeal deadlines are short, so check yours the day judgment is entered. A ruling on only some claims usually can't be appealed yet, because under Rule 54(b) it doesn't end the case unless the judge expressly finds no just reason for delay.
Sources & references
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, including Rule 56 (Summary Judgment) and Rules 4, 6, 12, 16 and 54 (Legal Information Institute)
- U.S. Supreme Court: Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317 (1986)
- U.S. Supreme Court: Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242 (1986)
- U.S. Supreme Court: Matsushita Electric Industrial Co. v. Zenith Radio Corp., 475 U.S. 574 (1986)
- 28 U.S.C. 1291 (final decisions) and 1746 (unsworn declarations under penalty of perjury)
- U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California: Civil Local Rules 7-1, 7-2, 7-3, 56-1 and 56-2
- California Code of Civil Procedure section 437c: Summary judgment and summary adjudication
- Supreme Court of Texas, Misc. Docket No. 26-9012: Final Approval of Amendments to Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 166a
- New York Civil Practice Law and Rules 3212 (summary judgment) and 2214 (motion papers)
- The Florida Bar: Florida Rules of Civil Procedure (October 1, 2026), rule 1.510
Video: A Closer Look
Third-party video for general background. It is not legal advice or an endorsement.
Talk to a Civil Litigation attorney near you
This guide is general information, not legal advice. For help with your specific situation, connect with a licensed attorney — many offer a free first consultation.
Find Civil Litigation Lawyers Near YouCivil Litigation lawyers by state
Firms our directory lists for civil litigation in the states where we have the most.


