
The questions to ask a lawyer in a consultation come down to five. How many cases like mine have you handled? What will the whole thing cost, and how is the fee figured? Who will do the work day to day? How will you keep me updated? Will you put our fee agreement in writing before you start?
This article is general legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by state and situation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your case, talk to a licensed attorney.
Key takeaways
- The ABA's model rule requires a lawyer to explain the fee and expenses at or soon after the start (preferably in writing) and requires a signed writing for any contingency fee.
- California requires a signed fee contract for hourly or flat-fee work when your total cost, fees included, will likely top $1,000.
- New York requires a letter of engagement unless the fee is expected to be under $3,000 or another exception applies.
- In Florida injury cases, you can cancel a contingency contract by written notice within 3 business days.
- A California lawyer without malpractice insurance must tell you so in writing when you hire them.
Can this lawyer handle your kind of case?
If these answers are weak, the fee questions don't matter much.
How many cases like mine have you handled, and how recently?
A lawyer who sees your type of case every month is more likely to know the local court and how the other side usually plays it. Listen for a rough number or share of the practice and a recent example. Be wary of "I handle everything," or years in practice offered when you asked about cases like yours.
Florida writes this question into the statement of client's rights that injury clients get before signing a contingency contract: you may ask about the lawyer's education, training and experience, and the lawyer should describe actual experience with similar cases.
What are the weak spots, and what outcomes are realistic?
Asking about weak spots tests whether the lawyer listened and will give you bad news. The answer you want is specific, such as a gap in your paperwork or a deadline that's close, along with a range of outcomes and what would move the result. A promise of a particular result or dollar figure at a first meeting should worry you.
Questions to ask a lawyer about fees and costs
Every answer in this group should end up in the written agreement.
How do you charge, and what will the whole case likely cost?
ABA Model Rule 1.5(b) requires the lawyer to explain the scope of the work and the basis or rate of the fee and expenses, preferably in writing, before or soon after starting, and to tell you about later changes. Listen for the hourly rate of each person who would bill time (or what a flat fee buys), a realistic range for the total, and what would raise it, such as a trial.
For a contingency fee, what percentage, and are expenses taken out before or after your share?
Under Model Rule 1.5(c), a contingency agreement must state the percentage at settlement, trial and appeal, the expenses deducted from the recovery, and whether they come out before or after the lawyer's percentage. That last detail changes your check. On a $60,000 settlement with $4,500 in expenses and a one-third fee, a fee taken from the full amount is $20,000 and you keep $35,500. Take the expenses out first and the fee is $18,500, leaving you $37,000.
Ask, too, whether the percentage rises once the other side answers the lawsuit. In Florida injury cases, a fee above 33 1/3% of the first $1 million is presumed clearly excessive if the case resolves before an answer is filed (40% after), unless a court approved it in advance. Florida medical malpractice clients keep at least 70% of the first $250,000 and 90% above that, unless they waive it in writing under oath.

Under the same model rule, a contingency agreement must also name any expenses you'll owe whether or not you win. Court costs, expert fees and deposition transcripts add up on a case that goes nowhere. Ask who pays them as the case moves along and whether you repay them after a loss. If you hear "don't worry about that," ask for the answer in writing.
How much do you need up front, and do I get back what isn't used?
Model Rule 1.15(c) puts fees and expenses paid in advance into a client trust account, to be withdrawn only as they're earned or incurred. California requires a prompt refund of any unearned advance when the representation ends, and allows a "non-refundable" label only for a true retainer (paid just to keep the lawyer available) that you agree to in writing. New York bans nonrefundable retainer fees, though a reasonable minimum fee clause in plain language is allowed. Ask where your deposit will sit and how you'll see it drawn down.
How often will you bill me, and what will the bills show?
California's fee statute requires every bill to show how the fee was figured and to list costs clearly. A California client who asks for a bill must get one within 10 days (or within 31 days of the last bill, if one went out in the 31 days before the request) and can ask again every 30 days. In any state, a lump-sum invoice with no detail is a warning sign.
Do you carry malpractice insurance?
This is the coverage that would pay if the lawyer's mistake cost you money. In California, a lawyer without it must tell a new client in writing at hiring, and a current client within 30 days of learning the coverage has ended. Work expected to take four hours or less, emergencies, and government and in-house lawyers are exempt. Elsewhere, ask anyway, since your state may not require the lawyer to raise it. A plain yes or no is a good answer.
Who will actually work on your case?
Who will handle my case day to day, and can I talk to them?
The lawyer across the table may not be the one who drafts your papers or returns your calls, which is fine if you know it and the price reflects it. Ask for names, roles and hourly rates. Florida requires injury lawyers to tell you before you sign whether they'll handle the case alone or with others, and its statement of client's rights lets you consult with each lawyer on the case.
Will you refer my case to another firm or bring one in?
Under Model Rule 1.5(e), lawyers in different firms can split a fee only if the split tracks each one's work or each accepts joint responsibility, you agree to the arrangement and each lawyer's share in an agreement confirmed in writing, and the total is reasonable. Texas requires your written consent before the referral happens, naming every firm and its share. Any referral plan should come up now, before you sign.
What happens after you hire them?
| Ask | A good answer sounds like | Be wary of |
|---|---|---|
| How will you keep me updated, and how fast do you return calls? | A routine you can hold them to, such as an email after every court date | "We'll be in touch," or slow replies before you've even signed |
| Will you tell me about every settlement offer? | Yes, every one, and the decision to settle is yours | "Leave the offers to me" |
| What happens next, and what do you need from me? | The next step, a rough date and a list of documents | No next step, or pressure to sign today |
Model Rule 1.4 requires a lawyer to keep you reasonably informed, respond promptly to reasonable requests for information, and explain enough for you to make informed decisions. In California, Rule 1.2 makes the decision to settle yours (in a criminal case, so are the plea, a jury waiver and whether you testify), and Rule 1.4.1 requires the lawyer to promptly pass along every term of a written settlement offer. For the last question, our Document Checklist lists the papers to gather for your type of case.

The ABA model rule prefers, but doesn't demand, a writing for hourly and flat fees. Some states go further.
| State and rule | Hourly or flat fee | Contingency fee |
|---|---|---|
| California: Bus. & Prof. Code 6147, 6148 | Contract signed by both of you when the total, fees included, will likely exceed $1,000; exceptions include emergencies and your written waiver | Contract signed by both of you, with a copy at signing, stating the rate, how costs affect your recovery and that the fee is negotiable (for medical malpractice, that the legal caps are maximums and a lower rate can be negotiated) |
| New York: 22 NYCRR Part 1215; Rule 1.5(c) | Letter of engagement or signed retainer covering scope, fees, expenses and billing, unless the fee is expected to be under $3,000 or another exception applies | A writing from the lawyer, promptly after you hire them, giving the percentages and how expenses are handled |
| Florida: Rule 4-1.5 | Preferably in writing for new clients; any nonrefundable fee must be confirmed in writing | Contract signed by you and the lawyer; injury cases add the statement of client's rights and the 3-business-day cancellation right |
| Texas: Disciplinary Rule 1.04(c), (d) | Preferably in writing for new clients | In writing, with the method, the percentage for each stage if they differ, and how expenses are deducted |
| Pennsylvania: Rule 1.5(b), (c) | In writing for new clients, before or soon after work starts | In writing, with the percentages and how expenses are deducted |
In California, a contract that breaks section 6147 or 6148 is voidable at your option, leaving the lawyer a reasonable fee. Section 6147 excludes workers' compensation cases, and section 6148 excludes corporate clients.
Family cases often have their own rules. New York's Part 1215 excludes domestic relations matters, but the lawyer still needs a written retainer signed by both of you and must give you a statement of client's rights and responsibilities at the first meeting, before you sign. Check your own state's fee rule too.
Checking the answers afterwards
Do these three things before you sign.
- Look the lawyer up on your state's attorney search for an active license in the state where your case is and any public discipline (open the order to see what it was for). Our guide on how to check if a lawyer is licensed walks through it.
- Read the engagement letter against your notes: the rate or percentage, what's excluded, expenses you'd owe after a loss, who does the work, and how either side can end it. A California contract under section 6148 must state the basis of compensation, the general nature of the services and each side's responsibilities. New York's letter must mention, where it applies, your right to fee arbitration under Part 137.
- Ask for anything missing to be added. In a Florida injury case, written notice within 3 business days of signing cancels the contract with no fee owed for that time, though you may owe costs the lawyer advanced.
When a contingency case ends, the model rule entitles you to a written statement of the outcome and, if there's a recovery, how your share was calculated. Florida's must also itemize costs, each firm's fee and payments to third parties.
After the meeting: deciding whether to hire
Write down each lawyer's answers within the hour and put them side by side. If the lawyers you're considering offer a free first meeting, comparing two or three costs you only time.
The lawyer to hire is usually the one whose answers were specific: real numbers on cost, a named person doing the work, an honest weak spot and a fee agreement you can take home and read. Keep looking if a lawyer wouldn't estimate the cost, pushed you to sign on the spot, promised a result, or went quiet for days before you'd paid anything. Our guide on how to choose a lawyer covers building the short list in the first place.
If you've been served with papers or have a court date, ask about deadlines first and decide quickly. Before your next meeting, the Consultation Prep tool builds a question list for your practice area, and you can find a general practice lawyer near you in our directory.
Sources & references
- American Bar Association: Model Rule 1.4, Communications
- American Bar Association: Model Rule 1.5, Fees
- American Bar Association: Model Rule 1.15, Safekeeping Property
- California Business and Professions Code, Article 8.5 (Fee Agreements), sections 6147 and 6148
- State Bar of California: Rules of Professional Conduct, Chapter 1 (Rules 1.2, 1.4.1, 1.4.2, 1.5, 1.15 and 1.16)
- New York State Unified Court System: 22 NYCRR Part 1215, Written Letter of Engagement
- New York Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.5 (22 NYCRR 1200.0): Fees and Division of Fees
- The Florida Bar: Rules Regulating The Florida Bar, Chapter 4 (Rule 4-1.5, Fees and Costs for Legal Services)
- Supreme Court of Texas: Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct (Rule 1.04, Fees)
- Pennsylvania Code: 204 Pa. Code Rule 1.5, Fees
Video: A Closer Look
Third-party video for general background. It is not legal advice or an endorsement.
Talk to a General Practice attorney near you
This guide is general information, not legal advice. For help with your specific situation, connect with a licensed attorney — many offer a free first consultation.
Find General Practice Lawyers Near YouGeneral Practice lawyers by state
Firms our directory lists for general practice in the states where we have the most.


